Stay informed with the LNN Daily Newsletter
Lethbridge-West MLA Shannon Phillips provided her reaction to the Alberta Budget 2023, March 1, 2023. (Photo: CHAT News Today)

MLA Phillips calls Alberta budget “fraudulent” and designed to buy votes

Mar 1, 2023 | 3:08 PM

LETHBRIDGE, AB – The MLA for Lethbridge-West is not holding back with her thoughts about the new provincial budget.

The Government of Alberta unveiled Budget 2023 on February 28, 2023, posting a surplus of $2.4 billion dollars and making investments into several areas.

NDP MLA Shannon Phillips, however, says it is not as rosy as the United Conservative Party (UCP) would like Albertans to believe.

“I think there is no question that it’s a fraudulent budget designed to buy a couple of votes ahead of the election, and then spring the costs onto Albertans after the polls have closed,” says Phillips. “It hides [Premier] Danielle Smith’s worst ideas, it sidelines Albertans’ real priorities. There are some very, very questionable rosy numbers in here, and for healthcare, it does not deliver the kinds of new services that people in Lethbridge are looking for.”

Phillips claims that the government’s economic forecasts do not align with any private sector analyses.

The province says in the 2023-26 Fiscal Plan that real GDP is forecast to rise by an average of three per cent in 2023 and 2024. The Conference Board of Canada, on the other hand, is projecting 2.1 per cent growth in 2023 and 2.8 per cent in 2024.

Phillips says Alberta is set up for “the most expensive summer ever” as she claims that several of the province’s affordability measures are set to end shortly after the provincial election this spring.

A statement from Affordability and Utilities Minister Matt Jones, however, says many of the affordability programs will continue beyond June 2023.

“Alberta’s Fuel Tax Relief and Natural Gas Price Protection programs have been made permanent, and will continue to save Albertans money and ensure they benefit from their owned resource[s],” says Jones. “Core supports programs including AISH, Income Support, the Alberta Seniors Benefit, and the Alberta Child and Family benefit have been indexed, and will continue to increase year over year. Income taxes have also been indexed, providing retroactive and ongoing tax relief to Albertans. Investments to provide affordable childcare, reductions to student loan interest, and caps on future tuition increases will also provide ongoing cost of living support.”

Phillips says the provincial budget does little for Lethbridge specifically.

The MLA states that there are several initiatives that have long since been identified as priorities for Lethbridge that did not receive funding, such as a catheterization lab and an expanded cardiac care unit at Chinook Regional Hospital, upgrades to the city’s water and wastewater treatment plant, and additional efforts to attract and retain healthcare workers.

Although the budget includes $11 million for an expansion of renal dialysis services at the hospital, Phillips says that had “always been planned.”

She called out her UCP counterpart in Lethbridge-East, Nathan Neudorf.

“It’s actually astonishing that the MLA for Lethbridge-East, who’s also the infrastructure minister, has delivered absolutely nothing for our city, absolutely nothing,” says Phillips. “We have a housing and homelessness crisis and a downtown business crisis in Lethbridge. We do not see any new investments in housing.”

Neudorf, on the other hand, says the budget hits on all of the top asks from the City of Lethbridge, including planning and constructing new schools, as well as healthcare, mental health and addictions, and Highway 3 twinning.

Overall, he says he believes that the budget is “punching above its weight class.” LNN will have more budget reactions from Neudorf on Thursday, March 2, 2023.

Phillips says the provincial budget would have looked a lot different if the Alberta NDP had been in power.

“What we would’ve seen is a stable, predictable plan to continue to invest in healthcare, so we do not see situations like we do in Lethbridge, where no one can have access – if you lost your family doctor, you cannot find another one,” says Phillips.

Phillips continues, “We would’ve seen a thoughtful plan for the surplus, not these just wildly-irresponsible vote-buying schemes and absolutely no plan for the surge in oil royalties.”

The new provincial budget was released approximately three months before the next provincial election, which is scheduled to be held on May 29, 2023.

Read more: UCP unveils budget it says secures Alberta’s future

Read more: Alberta budget includes $23 billion for infrastructure

Read more: Provincial investments aim to bolster public safety

Read more: Education budget supports hiring of 3,000 staff

Read more: Health care budget aims to tackle wait times and doctor shortage

Read more: Budget’s affordability measures total $2.3 B this year

Read more: Province to invest in mental health, addictions, social housing

For local news delivered daily to your email inbox, subscribe for free to the Lethbridge News Now newsletter here. You can also download the Lethbridge News Now mobile app in the Google Play and the Apple App Stores.